Created byFuzzy Cloud

Supreme Court of India

MAHA P. & ORS.versusTHE STATE OF KERALA & ORS.

Citation
2022 INSC 1311
Decided
22 July 2022
Disposal
Disposed off

Holding

The question of whether there was any extension of time beyond 2 March 2022 is not a matter for determination in these proceedings and must be decided in separate appropriate proceedings.

Summary

The Supreme Court was approached to modify its earlier order that the Government had allowed NRI candidates to cure attestation defects by 31 March 2022 in the context of NEET‑UG seats reserved for the NRI quota in Kerala private medical colleges. The State of Kerala contended that no such extension existed and that the actual last date for curing defects was 2 March 2022. The Court examined whether the question of an extension beyond 2 March 2022 fell within the scope of the present miscellaneous application. It held that this factual issue was not a matter for determination in the current proceedings. Consequently, the Court clarified that the issue must be decided in a separate appropriate proceeding on its own merits. The miscellaneous application for modification was therefore disposed of with the clarification.

Issues considered

  • Whether the Supreme Court's earlier statement that the deadline for NRI candidates to cure attestation defects was 31 March 2022 is correct.
  • Whether the question of any extension of the deadline beyond 2 March 2022 is within the jurisdiction of the present miscellaneous application.

Subjects

NEET‑UGNRI quotaMedical admissionAttestation defectExtension of timeMiscellaneous applicationProcedural jurisdiction

Judgment

                        [2022] 6 S.C.R. 817                            817


                        MAHA P. & ORS.                                 A
                                 v.
                THE STATE OF KERALA & ORS.
            Miscellaneous Application No. 1242 of 2022
                                                                       B
                                 In
                  (Civil Appeal No. 3654 of 2022)
                          JULY 22, 2022
        [DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD AND
                  A S BOPANNA, JJ.]                                    C

       Education/Educational Institutions: Medical admission —
NEET-UG – Matter pertaining to transferring of the seats reserved
for the NRI quota in private medical colleges in the State of Kerala
to the unreserved category – Order by this Court to the effect that    D
the Government had issued orders permitting NRI candidates to
cure defects in attestation by 31st March 2022 – Instant application
for modification by the State of Kerala stating that there was no
extension of the date for curing defects in attestation until 31st
March 2022 and the last date was, in fact, 02nd March 2022 –
Held: Issue as to whether there was any extension of time beyond       E
02nd March 2022 not a matter for determination in the proceedings
before this Court – Thus, the issue may be decided in appropriate
proceedings on its own merits.

      CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Miscellaneous Application          F
No. 1242 of 2022 in Civil Appeal No. 3654 of 2022.

      From the Judgment and Order dated 08.04.2022 of the High Court
of Kerala at Ernakulam in W.A. No. 485 of 2022.

     Haris Beeran, Mushtaq Salim, Usman Ghani Khan, Azhar Assees,      G
Radha Shyam Jena, Advs. for the Appellants.

      Nishe Rajen Shonker, Ms. Anu K. Joy, Alim Anvar, Sayid Marzook
Bafaki, Advs. for the Respondents.

                                                                       H
                                817
818                SUPREME COURT REPORTS                        [2022] 6 S.C.R.


A             The following Order of the Court was passed:

                                    ORDER
            1. In paragraph 2 of the judgment of this Court dated 18 May
      2022, it has been recorded that the Government had issued orders
B     permitting NRI candidates to cure defects in attestation by 31 March
      2022. This statement appears to be consistent with the facts set out in
      para 10 of the judgment of the Single Judge dated 4 April 2022.
             2. The State of Kerala has moved the application for modification
      stating that, as a matter of fact, there was no extension of the date for
C     curing defects in attestation until 31 March 2022 and the last date was,
      in fact, 2 March 2022. Mr Nishi Rajen Shonker, learned counsel states
      that the above sentence in the judgment of this court has given rise to
      another proceeding in the High Court.
            3. The issue as to whether there was any extension of time
D     beyond 2 March 2022 was not a matter for determination in the
      proceedings before this Court. The issue may, therefore, be decided in
      appropriate proceedings on its own merits on the basis of the record.
            4. The Miscellaneous Application is accordingly disposed of with
      the above clarification.
E

      Nidhi Jain                               Miscellaneous Application disposed of.




F




G




H


Search Indian case law

Ask in plain English, not just keywords. 25,000 AI words free, no card.

Try "NEET‑UG"Sign in to search

For a digitally signed copy suitable for filing, refer to the court's own website. Only the court can issue one.

MAHA P. & ORS. versus THE STATE OF KERALA & ORS. — 2022 INSC 1311 - Legal Desk AI